Wednesday, July 29, 2009
A little history
5 August 1961, Knox Church
Conductor Prof. Peter Platt
Soloists Dora Drake, Valda McCracken, Ninian Walder, Alistair Stokes, Ed Bohan and Anson Austin
Dunedin Concert Orchestra
17 April 1962, Dunedin Town Hall
Conductor Prof. Peter Platt
Soloists Heather Taylor, Valda McCracken, John Fisher, Arthur Bownie, Noel Signal, Alistair Stokes, Roy Coats
With the University Music Union Choir and the boys of St Paul's Cathedral Choir
Dunedin Concert Orchestra
8 April 1963, Dunedin Town Hall
Conductor Prof. Peter Platt
Soloists Anita Ritchie, Valda McCracken, Walter Robinson, Ed Bohan, Lucas Bunt
With the University Music Union Choir
Dunedin Concert Orchestra (augmented)
24 April 1979, Dunedin Town Hall
Conductor Peter Warwick
Soloists Robert Oliver, Roger Wilson, Ruth Hawkey, Sally Banks, Peter Williams, Haward Harvey
Dunedin Civic Orchestra
2 April 1980, Dunedin Town Hall
Conductor Peter Warwick
Soloists Anthony Benfell, Roger Wilson, Pam Blanchard, Judith Borick, Harvey Brown
With the trebles of ST Paul's Cathedral and Knox Church Choirs
Dunedin Civic Orchestra
The above five performances were sung from the Choir's own scores of the Elgar/Atkins edition in English.
20 March 2005, Dunedin Town Hall
Conductor David Burchell
Soloists David Hamilton, Pepe Becker, David Hansen, David Griffiths, Grant Dixon, Shaun Dixon
Southern Sinfonia.
This performance was in German.
All performances were organised by the Dunedin Choral Society, later called Scola Cantorum and then City of Dunedin Choir, with members of the University Music Union and Cathedral Choirs joining in some performances.
Thanks to Hugh Montgomery for researching the archives.
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
Progress
Thursday, July 16, 2009
Skiving off City Choir to sing in Wellington
I wasn't at City Choir on Tuesday because I was in Wellington on holiday. Naughty me. Send me to the naughty corner. No dessert tonight.
However...I did take the chance, while there, to sing with the wonderful Orpheus Choir.
They're performing the Verdi Requiem this weekend, so I got the chance to sight-sing the fugues (and everything else) at full speed, with no preparation! What fun!
I've done the Verdi before, but it was nearly a decade ago, and as a second Alto. So the First Soprano line was new to me.
We also sang the Polovtsian Dances, another piece I'd done before as an Alto, but not as a Soprano. And straight after rehearsal I had to text my great mate Philip Legge to tell him they were using his score from the CPDL. He was pleased to hear it.
I had a whale of a time. The Orpheus Choir made me very welcome, and my fellow Sopranos said they'd love to welcome any City Choir members who happen to venture up to Wellington and have a spare Tuesday night. They rehearse from 7:30 to 9:30, same as us.
Anyway, while I was there, between a few sopranos and myself we hatched a very tentative and cunning plan to do a massed choir performance of Bach's Christmas Oratorio in Wellington sometime soon.
Maybe next year, if we can convince David and Michael Fulcher (their conductor). We haven't mentioned the idea to either of the men yet, but I guess this blog post is shoving the idea out into the open, isn't it? Hehehe.
Orpheus sopranos are aching to do the Bach, and were apparently quite jealous when they heard we sang the piece last year.
You can read about my adventures in Wellington in full at my blog, The Chorister - here's a link to the post Get your Wellies on - and sing!
So yes, I was naughty. I wasn't at City Choir. But I DID attend rehearsal!
Wednesday, July 15, 2009
Haydn - Missa in Angustiis : 1 Kyrie
Haydn - Missa in Angustiis : 7 Et resurrexit
Haydn - Missa in Angustiis : 8 Sanctus
Haydn - Missa in Angustiis : 9 Benedictus
Haydn - Missa in Angustiis : 10 Agnus Dei
Rebecca Ryan
This is a biography for Rebecca Ryan, who will be the Soprano Soloist in the Haydn Nelson Mass. She was in the Music Department's Carmen a few years ago. She is an Otago graduate. I have the Naxos recording of the Handel Coronation Anthems, and she sings the Handel Cantata Silete venti on this disc, which is quite a brilliant piece for the soprano.
The Haydn Nelson Mass is also a brilliant piece for the Soprano soloist - the sop must have been the only good soloist available to Haydn, and she does most of the solo work.
Monday, July 6, 2009
What the reviewer said
Mellow sounds from the Southern Sinfonia and the City of Dunedin Choir, with excellent highlights from soprano Lois Johnston, alto Claire Barton, tenor Stephen Chambers and bass baritone Andreas Hirt, directed by David Burchell and Michael Dawson, warmed a medium-sized audience at St Paul's on Saturday.
The programme celebrated the anniversaries of Purcell, Handel, Haydn and Felix Mendelssohn. It covered two hundred years of choral music and, as the programme notes inform us, the foundations of of the English sound.
While this demanding programme occasionally taxed the stamina of the choir, and while Barton seemed to be at less than her best, Johnston's strong confidence on the heights, Hirt's and Chambers' rich musicality and the excellent blend of all voices, and some good highlights from the woodwinds, brass and cellos, delivered some real pleasure.
Purcell's joyous welcome Come ye sons of art has a sweetness which lingers in the ear, but was unfortunately marred by a lack of vigour. The languorous invitation diluted the sense of impending fun.
Haydn's Spring taken from The Seasons was, despite the sense of joy in the words, a musically ordered, balanced and mild change of season at times frustratingly poles apart from Vivaldi's exuberance.
Handel's My Heart is Inditing, introducing Michael Dawson as conductor, was performed with good lilt. Dawson is commended for the precise performance from the choir. However, the words of the concluding exultation "Kings shall be thy nursing fathers" are a bit hard to swallow. If sensored out, we would be left with the more palatable scenario of the "King shall have pleasure in thy beauty".
Mendelssohn's As the Hart Pants gave ample opportunity to celebrate the excellent balance of solo voices with the choir. The closing work, Handel's The King Shall Rejoice, though a little perfunctory and occasionally muddied, made a successfully triumphant close.
Solists, choir and Southern Sinfonia under the excellent direction of Burchell and Dawson contributed to a delightful, homogeneous evening. Bravo.
What the audience said
"Hugely enjoyed the concert yesterday afternoon - it really was wonderful. You all looked wonderful - and sounded so polished."
"The performance was excellent."
1, 2, 3, 4 - We're City Choir, now hear us roar!
In fact, I was going to title this blog post "Yeeee haaaaw!" but I don't think Purcell, with his very pretty, curly wig, would have approved. Then again, with his lame in-jokes and buckle shoes, maybe he would have. Who knows?
Purcell - Come, Ye Sons Of Art
One thing that is certain is that he would have approved mightily of our rendition of "Come Ye Sons Of Art" with which our "Anniversary Accolades" concert opened. We tuned our voices, our instruments played, and it was all just beautiful. I could see the audience grooving along to the music, bopping their heads in time to the beat, and as I was singing I couldn't help thinking "Yeah, baby! We're rocking this town!"

Haydn - Seasons (Spring)
On to the next dead white guy, it was time for us to nail Haydn's "Seasons" - the "Spring" part of it anyway! More in-jokes with parts of the score that sounded rather familiar to those of us who know other works by this composer - but hey, what's a bit of self-plagiarism between friends? It's nice to know that these guys weren't as dismally-minded as their rather staid press shots would lead one to suspect:
.jpg)
Personally, I think Haydn hated sopranos. I mean, anyone who writes top B Nasties for choir sopranos that run on for nearly two full bars is asking for a fight. I'd deck him if he were alive today. Lucky for him he's not. But my fellow sopranos did a magnificent job - page 53 wasn't the first, or the last, point in the night that I was tremendously proud of the women of City Choir. We took that B Nasty and told Haydn exactly what he could do with it!
Not only were we singing well, but the Sinfonia and our soloists were sounding wonderful. In particular, Stephen Chambers, our Tenor soloist, was worth a mention. He sounded glorious, his diction and tuning spot on. While all the soloists were great, I particularly enjoyed his performance.
Two works down, it's half time, we're looking good. Several very snarly passages are under our belts, and it is time to grab a quick gulp of water and do a quick dash to the loo before we're back on stage in our sardine-esque positions.
Handel - My Heart Is Inditing
We're on for Handel with the wonderful Michael Dawson at the helm. And not only does Michael do an incredibly job in his orchestral debut, guiding us through the not-exactly-easy twists and turns of Handel, but he is also obviously completely in control of the excellent Sinfonia.
A few words of thanks
While I'm talking about Michael, I also want to say something about the fact that David has been generous and thoughtful enough to give Michael this opportunity. Few choral directors would have shown the trust and respect that David has in Michael. He has been supportive of Michael not just in City Choir, but also in St Pauls Cathedral Choir.
It is so important not just to direct a Choir and Orchestra well, as David does, but also to raise the next generation to follow in your footsteps. I can't say enough about how important this job is, and how highly I think of David for giving this opportunity to Michael in such a respectful way. Both men were a credit to City Choir and to Dunedin this weekend. I think we are all very fortunate to have them.
Back to the concert
At this point in the concert we were getting our teeth into "My Heart Is Inditing" with Michael. From where I was standing, the diction was good and clear, the notes precise, and the choir and audience attentive. The movements worked well. I'll admit I'm a bit of a fan of Handel - more so than of Purcell especially, or of Haydn. Purcell always sounds a bit wrong to me - like it was written for different tuning, or something. Don't ask me what exactly - I'm no music expert - but know what I hear. The chords don't quite fit together, and the notes somehow don't feel quite confortable with one another. They rub against each other as enemies, not as friends.
Handel, on the other hand, always feels bright and correct to me, and it did last night. It sits well in the voice, and if we had a few issues with pitch, they were not noticed by the audience as far as I could see. Michael had good contact with the choir, and overall the movements came off well.

Mendelssohn - As The Hart Pants
On to the last of our four composers - Mendelssohn. Mendelssohn is often touted as a composer who writes particularly well for the voice, and "As The Hart Pants" is a good example of his work. He works up to the high notes for the sopranos rather than dumping them at you, and the body of the line sits comfortably within your range, so you never feels stressed or strained when singing his work. Maybe this is why I like Mendelssohn, even though I don't much like this particular translation of the biblical text.
"As The Hart Pants" started off beautifully with the alto entry, and the altos entered so well that I really wished I was back singing alto again, like when I first started singing in choirs! They just sounded so smooth, so rich, and so beautifully in tune. It was a pleasure to listen to. The first movement in particular was performed well overall, especially in the second concert, when I think we peformed it better than in any rehearsal. Which is as it should be.
I am also really pleased to say that our men nailed No 6 "The Lord Hath Commanded". They really did well, and I know this had been particularly difficult for them in rehearsal, requiring a four part split. They did so well in both concerts. Yay us!
The Mendelssohn ends with my favourite of all choral playtimes - a fugue. Yeee haaaaw! I love fugues! Just the way all the lines deviate and fit together and pull apart, then come back together again, translating the melody in different ways and recreating the theme in each choral line. A good fugue is musical magic. I'm not a music theorist, who could no doubt tell you about contrapuntal composition and fugal subjects, and all that highfalutin stuff. Not me. Instead I'll just tell you it was great fun to sing, and I'd love to do it all again today, and tomorrow, and the next day, because fugues are just awesome. Brain food for the soul.

Handel - The King Shall Rejoice
Finally, to end the concert, it was back to Handel with David conducting "The King Shall Rejoice", which includes my favourite movement - No. 2 "Exceeding Glad Shall He Be", which is Handel trying his hand at Bluegrass music. It really is - I'm not joking! My only grumble is I was a little disappointed that of the Coronation Anthems we weren't doing "Zadok The Priest", which is a fabulous piece and a great sing - maybe next time!
The "Alleluia" was our closing movement, and it did stay together, despite worries in rehearsal. All eyes were on the conductor - I was too nervous to even look down on my score in some moments! We followed closely and tightly, and the piece worked. Friends in the audience told me the work was wonderful, and that they enjoyed it thoroughly, as they had enjoyed the works of the other composers.
In conclusion...
Four Important Dead Guys. Four major works. Four anniversaries. Four accolades. We came, we sang, we did them justice. City Choir once again proved that we can take on a huge amount of music and make it work. I think my extra work outside of rehearsal paid off - I know that others in the choir studied the music at home too, and their work paid off too.
Now we have a week of doing nothing. No music for a week, and I'm off on holiday next weekend up to the north island for a few days, for a well-deserved rest.
Next concert isn't until September, with Haydn's Nelson Mass. It seems so long away, but right now all I can think is, Bring it on!
Sunday, July 5, 2009
It was cold, .. no really, it was!
This is us rehearsing on Saturday afternoon. During a patch where the orchestra are practicing their bit. Note scarves, hats, overcoats...

... and mittens!

The only person wearing just a shirt was David; clearly waving your arms around in a meaningful fashion (aka conducting) is sufficient exercise to keep warm.
We had been forewarned. Friday evening rehearsal was distinctly chilly, even though the heating had been on for six hours. The Cathedral is, after all, a large space to heat.
So, a decision was made that meant that the ladies could wear dress black pants for the performance. Though suggested Judy the long black skirts were more forgiving of things that could be worn underneath to keep warm. I checked with her today, and true to her word, she admitted she had on tights, a pair of long-johns, and black socks tucked into her boots. However, what she hadn't realised was that I had managed to wear my summer weight track-pants (usually worn in the garden) under my dress pants!
So if we moved onto the 'stage' rather sedately, it was due in part at least, to lots of layers of clothing under our choir uniform!
Never mind, hope you all enjoyed it ... we did!
Saturday, July 4, 2009
Hillarious moments in rehearsal
David Burchell, our esteemed conductor, has a wonderful sense of humour, but these utterings were quite innocent and unintentionally funny, which makes it even more enjoyable.
He was talking to the tenors and basses, trying to encourage them to sing with confidence in a passage where the two voices were rather exposed, so he says to them: "You have no ladies on top of you at this point..." - and we all cracked up! The gents should be so lucky... ??!!
And then there was the bit where he was organising sits and stands. When we enter stage, someone has to keep an eye on proceedings and when everyone has filed onto the stage, give the signal so we can all sit down together. So he asks alto Rosi Crane who stands at the far end: "Rosi, can you see the last ones on without too much craning?" Again - raucous laughter. I don't think the orchestra got this one; they did not know Rosi's surname is Crane!
Good luck to all for tonight's performance; it's going to be very good! And then we get to do it all again on Sunday - yippee!!
Wednesday, July 1, 2009
Anniversary Accolades coming soon

Anniversary Accolades - Celebrating Classic Choral Composers
St Paul's Cathedral, Dunedin
Get your tickets NOW!!!
The City of Dunedin Choir presents music by Handel, Purcell, Mendelssohn and Haydn. In 2009 we celebrate 200 years since the birth of Mendelssohn, 350 years since the birth of Purcell, 200 years since the death of Haydn and 250 years since the death of Handel.
* Handel: The King Shall Rejoice
* Purcell: Come ye Sons of Art (Birthday Ode for Queen Mary)
* Mendelssohn: As the Hart Pants (Psalm 42)
* Handel: My Heart is Inditing
* Haydn: The Seasons - Spring
The soloists are soprano Lois Johnston, alto Claire Barton, tenor Stephen Chambers and baritone Andreas Hirt, and the conductor is David Burchell.
The Choir gratefully acknowledges the valuable assistance received from:
Dunedin City Council, The Southern Trust, Bendigo Valley Sports & Charity Foundation, Perry Foundation